The man on the Worcester Cathedral tomb had once been an unlikely prospect for the crown. King John of England had three older brothers ahead of him in the succession, and was not expected to become king.
He was about 5 ft 5 in (1.65 m) tall, with a barrel-chested body and dark red hair. His contemporaries thought he looked like an inhabitant of Poitou.
John also accumulated books. His library travelled with him, through a life that would take him from an Oxford childhood to a contested throne.
Birth and Family, Oxford
John was born in Oxford around Christmastide, with Westminster Abbey giving his birthday as 24 December and accepting 1167 as the year favoured by many scholarly sources. He was the youngest of the eight known children of Henry II and Eleanor of Aquitaine. The historian Marc Morris links the uncertainty about his birth date to that position in the family.
Beaumont Palace stood outside Oxford’s north gate. A commemorative stone records the births there of Richard I in 1157 and John in 1167.
Henry II was King of England and held the titles Duke of Normandy and Count of Anjou by inheritance; his marriage to Eleanor made him Duke of Aquitaine too. Eleanor, duchess of Aquitaine in her own right, had previously been married to King Louis VII of France.
John was given to a wet nurse shortly after his birth. Eleanor left for Poitiers and sent him and his sister Joan to Fontevrault Abbey.
Lackland, Ireland and the Rebellion Against Richard
Henry II nicknamed his youngest son Lackland because there was initially no provision of lands for him. The joke came from his father. The historian Stephen Church calls it a “less than supportive jibe”.
John Lackland acquired a lordship in 1177, when Henry II replaced William FitzAldelm as Lord of Ireland with his ten-year-old son at the Council of Oxford. John’s older brother Young Henry died in 1183; John made his first journey to Ireland in 1185 with 300 knights and administrators. The expedition failed, and John offended Irish rulers by mocking their long beards. He returned to England that year and blamed the viceroy Hugh de Lacy; Pope Lucius III had refused to agree to his proclamation as King of Ireland.
Geoffrey, who held Brittany, died in 1186. Richard succeeded Henry II in 1189 and recognised Geoffrey’s baby son Arthur as his heir.
John tried to seize control in 1193, during Richard’s absence on crusade and imprisonment in Germany, and allied himself with Philip Augustus of France. Richard returned in 1194. John fled to Normandy.
Richard forgave his brother, then 27 years old, and called him “a child who has had evil counsellors”, but removed his lands apart from Ireland. The succession changed again after Philip II captured Arthur in 1196. Richard then named John his heir.
Accession and the Rival Claim of Arthur of Brittany
Richard died on 6 April 1199 from a crossbow wound received at the siege of Châlus, without legitimate children to succeed him. John’s claim rested on his being Henry II’s sole surviving son, while Arthur I of Brittany claimed through his father Geoffrey. Norman law favoured John. Angevin law favoured Arthur.
The divisions extended beyond the law. The barons of England and Normandy supported John, while Brittany and Anjou preferred the 12-year-old Arthur, whose claim had the backing of Philip Augustus. William Marshal and Hubert Walter debated the alternatives: Walter initially leaned towards Arthur, but both eventually agreed to support John.
King John of England was crowned at Westminster Abbey on 27 May 1199, with his mother Eleanor supporting his claim. Westminster Abbey records his “unseemly levity” during the ceremony. He left before receiving the Sacrament.
The Treaty of Le Goulet followed in May 1200. Philip recognised John as Richard’s heir to his French lands, and John accepted Philip as their feudal overlord. Marc Morris gives the payment Philip demanded as 20,000 marks (£13,333), alongside recognition of his lordship over the continental possessions.
Some English chroniclers contrasted the peace with Richard’s conduct and called the new king “John Softsword”.
Two Wives and Many Children
John married Isabella of Gloucester at Marlborough Castle on 29 August 1189. They were related within the third degree and had no papal dispensation, so Archbishop Baldwin of Forde placed John under interdict. The papal legate John of Agnani later lifted it. Permission for the marriage was never given.
Isabella of Gloucester was not crowned alongside John in May 1199. The marriage was annulled on grounds of consanguinity, with Marc Morris placing the annulment by the end of 1200.
King John of England married Isabella of Angoulême at Angoulême on 24 August 1200, and she was crowned at Westminster Abbey on 8 October 1200. She had been betrothed to Hugh de Lusignan. Her age at the wedding remains uncertain.
The historian Nicholas Vincent describes John as “downright mean” to Isabella of Angoulême, while the historian William Chester Jordan calls them a “companionable couple”. They had five legitimate children. Henry III was born at Winchester Castle on 1 October 1207, followed by Richard on 5 January 1209 and Joan on 22 July 1210. Isabella was born in 1214 and Eleanor in 1215.
Joan married Alexander II of Scotland, while Isabella married Emperor Frederick II. John’s illegitimate children included Richard FitzRoy and Geoffrey, as well as Oliver fitz Regis and Osbert Gifford. Another daughter, Joan, known as Siwan, married Llywelyn the Great.
By January 1214 John had arranged Isabella of Gloucester’s marriage to Geoffrey FitzGeoffrey de Mandeville, Earl of Essex, who promised 20,000 marks for the match. She died on 14 October 1217.
Mirebeau, Arthur’s Disappearance and the Loss of Normandy
According to BBC History, John’s marriage to the heiress Isabella of Angoulême triggered war with France, and he failed to appear before Philip II. Arthur’s forces threatened Eleanor at Mirebeau in 1202. John reached her with William de Roches and captured Arthur and the rebel leadership in July or August.
Twenty-two captured rebels died in bad conditions. In February 1203 John ordered more than 20 nobles to be taken to Corfe Castle, where they starved.
Arthur had been born on 29 March 1187 and had been Duke of Brittany since 1196. After his capture, he was held at Falaise under Hubert de Burgh’s guard, then transferred to Rouen under William de Braose. The chronicler Ralph of Coggeshall reported that John ordered Arthur to be blinded and castrated.
Arthur disappeared from Rouen Castle around Easter 1203. His precise fate remains uncertain, although he was almost certainly murdered on John’s orders. The Margam annals accused John directly, saying that after dinner, when he was drunk, “he slew him with his own hand, and tying a heavy stone to the body cast it into the Seine”.
Gaillard fell in March 1204. Eleanor died the following month, and by August Philip had taken Normandy and Anjou, together with Poitou. King John of England retained only Aquitaine of those continental possessions.
The Quarrel with Pope Innocent III
Hubert Walter, Archbishop of Canterbury, died on 13 July 1205, and the choice of his successor brought John into conflict with Pope Innocent III. John wanted John de Gray, Bishop of Norwich, while the Canterbury chapter favoured its sub-prior Reginald. Innocent rejected both candidates. He appointed Stephen Langton instead.
Innocent consecrated Langton in June 1207, but John barred him from England and seized church lands. The pope imposed an interdict on England in March 1208. Clergy could no longer hold services apart from baptisms of the young and confession and absolution for the dying.
Innocent excommunicated King John of England in November 1209. The excommunication lasted until 1213, while the ban on services remained until 1214. One contemporary estimate put the income John took during the dispute at up to 14% of the English Church’s annual revenue.
John accepted the papal terms in May 1213 before the legate Pandulf Verraccio at the Templar Church at Dover. He surrendered England to the papacy under an arrangement requiring an annual payment of 1,000 marks: 700 marks for England and 300 marks for Ireland.
The agreement was formalised in the Bulla Aurea, or Golden Bull. Innocent supported John for the remainder of his reign.
John as King at Home: Justice, Taxes and the Barons
John spent longer in England than his predecessors and took an active part in administration, with his presence making royal government more personal even in the north. The historian Lewis Warren credits his zeal for justice with a contribution to English common law, although fees may also have motivated him. His legal system covered free men only.
King John of England levied scutage eleven times during seventeen years on the throne, as often as the preceding three monarchs combined. The tax on income and movable goods in 1207 produced £60,000. The 1210 tallage on the Jews raised £44,000, while annual royal income rose from about £25,000 at the start of the reign to a peak of £145,000 in 1211.
William de Braose refused to pay 40,000 marks. John imprisoned his wife Maud and a son, both of whom died; de Braose himself died in exile in 1211. Inheritance also brought substantial demands. William FitzAlan paid 10,000 marks for his father’s barony in 1214.
John invaded Scotland and forced William to accept the Treaty of Norham, with its requirement for a payment of £10,000. In 1210 he took a large army to Ireland to crush a rebellion. His journeys into Wales were more frequent: he visited every year from 1204 to 1211.
Many of the disaffected barons came from northern England and were known as the Northerners. Many owed John large sums.
The 1214 Campaign and the Battle of Bouvines
John sailed for Poitou in February 1214 to attempt the recovery of Normandy. Many barons refused to serve. Mercenaries filled the gaps in his forces, while Emperor Otto IV and Renaud of Boulogne joined Ferdinand of Flanders as his allies, with William Longespée supporting them.
The plan required two advances against Philip’s forces. John would push north-east from Poitou while the allied army marched south-west from Flanders. The aim was to force Philip to divide his attention between them.
John had retaken Anjou by the end of June and laid siege to Roche-au-Moine. The Angevin nobles refused to advance, however, and Prince Louis blocked him; John retreated to La Rochelle. On 9 July 1214 he wrote to the barons who had not accompanied him and asked them to join him without delay.
Philip Augustus defeated Otto IV’s larger allied army at Bouvines, near Lille, on 27 July 1214. John subsequently handed Anjou back to Philip and paid compensation under a truce intended to last six years. The Pope deposed Otto IV.
King John of England returned home in October 1214 with his funds exhausted.
Magna Carta and Runnymede
The rebel barons renounced their fealty to John at Northampton on 5 May 1215 and chose Robert fitz Walter as their leader. London welcomed them on 17 May 1215. The city held John’s treasury and exchequer.
John met the rebels at Runnymede, between Windsor Castle and Staines, on 10 June 1215. They presented the Articles of the Barons, and Stephen Langton mediated as their demands became the document later known as Magna Carta, meaning Great Charter.
King John of England set his seal to the text on 15 June 1215. The rebels renewed their oaths on 19 June, when copies were issued. Nobody signed the charter. The barons did not attach seals either.
The charter promised protection for church rights and against illegal imprisonment. It also required swift justice and baronial consent for new taxation. Clause 61 established a council of 25 barons, with authority to seize John’s castles if he failed to comply within 40 days.
At least thirteen original copies were issued in 1215, seven on 24 June. Four survive: two at the British Library, with another at Salisbury Cathedral and another at Lincoln Castle.
Innocent III excommunicated the rebel barons on 7 July 1215, and papal bulls of 24-25 August declared Magna Carta null and void. The pope called it “not only shameful and demeaning, but illegal and unjust”. John wrote to him on 13 September 1215.
Clauses 1, 9 and 29 of the 1297 version have never been repealed. Clause 29 protects freemen from imprisonment except by the lawful judgment of their peers or the law of the land.
The First Barons’ War and Prince Louis
John besieged Rochester Castle in October 1215 after breaking Rochester Bridge and taking the bailey. His miners undermined the keep’s south-east turret. On 25 November he wrote: “Send to us with all speed by day and night, forty of the fattest pigs of the sort least good for eating so that we may bring fire beneath the castle”.
The timber props were burned with pig fat, and a corner of the keep collapsed. Starvation forced the surrender on 30 November 1215. Savari de Mauléon persuaded John not to hang the garrison, although one bowman was hanged.
The Barnwell Chronicle recorded the resistance: “No one alive can remember a siege so fiercely pressed and so manfully resisted”.
John campaigned across the Midlands and East Anglia in early 1216, and north as far as Berwick-upon-Tweed. In January he fought against Alexander II of Scotland.
The rebel barons invited Prince Louis of France to take the throne. Louis claimed through his wife Blanche of Castile, a granddaughter of Henry II, and landed at Sandwich in Kent in May 1216 after storms scattered John’s fleet.
King John of England retreated west. London welcomed Louis, and John’s half-brother William Longespée deserted to the rebels.
The Wash, Death at Newark and Burial at Worcester
John passed through Bishop’s Lynn, now King’s Lynn, in October 1216, when his baggage train was caught by quicksands and the tide on the Wash. The chronicler Roger of Wendover left a graphic account of the disaster. The losses may have amounted to only a few pack-horses.
John contracted dysentery at Lynn and had already suffered from gout since 1215. On 15 October 1216 he wrote from Newark Castle to Pope Honorius III to ask for absolution.
King John of England died at Newark Castle on the night of 18/19 October 1216, during a thunderstorm, aged 48 or 49. William Marshal was among those present. Ralph of Coggeshall reported that people had “dreadful and fantastical visions” of John that night.
The accounts of death by poisoned ale or poisoned plums are probably fictitious. So is the story of a surfeit of peaches, which Westminster Abbey records in a version involving cider.
John’s will requested burial at Worcester Cathedral. He was placed in front of St Wulfstan’s altar, between the shrines of St Wulfstan and St Oswald, while his heart was buried separately at Croxton Abbey.
His tomb carries England’s oldest royal effigy, carved in Purbeck marble and dated by the V&A to around 1240. When the coffin was opened in 1797, a monk’s cowl was found inside.
Reputation and Legacy
William Marshal became protector of John’s nine-year-old son Henry III, who was crowned at Gloucester on 28 October 1216. The regency reissued Magna Carta in an edited form. Peace with Louis followed in the Treaty of Lambeth in September 1217, and Edward I confirmed the charter in 1297.
Roger of Wendover and Matthew Paris helped establish John’s negative reputation. Paris called him a “tyrant rather than a king”. His claim that John had tried to convert to Islam is considered untrue.
Tudor writers gave John a different part. John Foxe portrayed him as an early Protestant hero, whereas Walter Scott’s Ivanhoe and Howard Pyle’s Robin Hood made him the villain of the Robin Hood story. The earliest tales name their king Edward.
The historian John Gillingham describes John as “one of the worst kings ever to rule England”. Ralph Turner and Lewis Warren also regard him as unsuccessful, but argue that the chroniclers exaggerated his failings. The historian Jim Bradbury notes agreement about his work as an administrator.
John streamlined financial record-keeping in the pipe rolls. No later English monarch has been called John.
King John of England at a Glance
When was King John of England born?
John was born in Oxford around Christmastide. Westminster Abbey gives 24 December and identifies 1167 as the year accepted by many scholarly sources.
How did King John die?
He contracted dysentery at Lynn in October 1216 and died at Newark Castle on the night of 18/19 October 1216. He was aged 48 or 49. Stories of poisoning or a surfeit of peaches are probably fictitious.
Who were John’s wives?
King John of England married Isabella of Gloucester on 29 August 1189; the marriage was annulled on grounds of consanguinity. He married Isabella of Angoulême on 24 August 1200. They had five legitimate children, including Henry III.
Why was he called Lackland?
Henry II gave John the nickname because there was initially no provision of lands for his youngest son. The historian Stephen Church calls the joke a “less than supportive jibe”.
What did King John do with Magna Carta?
He set his seal to the charter on 15 June 1215, after negotiations with the rebel barons at Runnymede. Papal bulls of 24-25 August declared it null and void. Henry III’s regency later reissued an edited version.
How long did John reign?
King John of England reigned for seventeen years. He was crowned on 27 May 1199 and died in October 1216. His son Henry III was crowned at Gloucester on 28 October 1216.
